polyphony · claude-opus-5-5

R1: All principal canon characters appear with correct names and roles, and no major invented characters or misbehaviors are present. | R6: The outline faithfully follows the confirmed premise, each act’s turn is realized, every chapter shows change, and the chapter count matches the request. | R3: No text was provided to evaluate against the outlined beats, so it fails the rubric entirely.

scene 1 R1: All principal characters required appear correctly and behave as canon describes, with no deviations. | scene 1 R2: Only half the lines can be confidently matched to the correct character, and the voices lack clear distinguishing diction from the samples. | scene 1 R3: All planned beats appear in correct order with their required changes and no unplanned material. | scene 1 R4: The scene maintains consistent first‑person‑like limited POV in past tense, matches tone, has varied concrete sentences, and contains no structural violations. | scene 1 R5: The prose aligns with canon and planned beats, contains no contradictions, and fulfills the continuity requirements fully. | scene 2 R1: All required canon characters appear correctly and act as described, with no extraneous or mischaracterized figures. | scene 2 R2: The provided lines lack any evidence of distinct voices matching the samples, making characters indistinguishable. | scene 2 R3: The scene includes all five planned beats in the correct order, with each described change occurring as specified and no extra unplanned events. | scene 2 R4: The scene maintains consistent POV and tense, matches the courteous menace tone, and reads as publishable prose with only minor stylistic slips. | scene 2 R5: The scene aligns with the canon and prior text without contradictions, meeting continuity fully. | scene 3 R1: All principal characters required for this beat (Aldous Kerr and Count Vasska) appear correctly and act according to canon, with no missing or mischaracterized figures. | scene 3 R2: No dialogue was provided to assess voice distinctness, so attribution cannot be made. | scene 3 R3: All four planned beats appear in the correct order with their required changes, and no unplanned major events are added. | scene 3 R4: The scene maintains consistent first‑person‑limited past tense POV, matches the tone and rhythm of the brief, and is a polished, publishable‑draft without structural errors. | scene 3 R5: The scene aligns with canon and planned beats, contains no contradictions, and faithfully follows the continuity requirements. | scene 4 R1: All required canon characters (Aldous Kerr and Count Vasska) appear correctly and act as described, with no extraneous or mischaracterized figures. | scene 4 R2: With only a single ambiguous line, the evaluator cannot attribute ≥50% of lines to distinct voices, failing the rubric. | scene 4 R3: All five planned beats appear sequentially, each realized as described, with no extra or out‑of‑order material. | scene 4 R4: The passage maintains consistent POV and past tense, matches the intended tone and style, and is free of structural errors, with only minor occasional phrasing slips. | scene 4 R5: The prose aligns with canon and prior text, containing no contradictions and fulfills all planned beats.